Blind vs. sighted tastings

June 2, 2010
by Christian
in Opinion & Analysis
with 1 Comment
Sohia Loren

Sohia Loren

Grace Kelly

Grace Kelly might not have been live for very long, but it seems it is already causing a stir. Neil Pendock noted on his blog Pendock Uncorked that  according to my potted CV (here) I will now also be a taster for Platter’s which operates sighted, in addition to continuing to chair the WINE magazine tasting panel which operates blind (labels out of sight). This caused Mr Pendock to postulate that followers of South African wine can expect “far greater correlation between the tasting assessments of two of the largest players”.

I sincerely hope this is the case but won’t be surprised if it is not. To my mind, blind vs. sighted tastings are not mutually exclusive and both have something to offer when it comes to wine judging: blind tasting deals with the construction of a wine in a mechanical sense (how well put together it is) at a certain point of time while sighted tasting deals with issues of pedigree and long-term potential. See Michael Fridjhon’s well argued article in this regard here.

One further point that I have made before but which bears repeating is that insisting on reliability (in the sense of repeatability of function) is only partially relevant when it comes to wine judging. Just as important is validity in the sense of a tasting coming up with a plausible outcome (whether by acknowledging a “seeded player” or identifying an “emerging talent”). Many dismiss wine competitions as “beauty shows” but to me that’s precisely what they are: Grace Kelly and Sophia Loren are both beautiful and either could have won the pageant on the day.

Tagged , ,

Share this post

One Comment

  1. EverydayWinoJune 2, 2010 at 5:04 pmReply

    Both certainly have value. Taking part in both the value of the critical (blind – often the start of a wines pedigree) vs the supportive (more than a sipp and further scrutiny) is essential to differentiate. Wine DRINKERS THESE ARE ONLY GUIDES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


AEC v1.0.4
  • No upcoming events
AEC v1.0.4
newlstter2 Get the biggest stories of the past fortnight sent directly to your inbox. subscribe

Wine magazine was published from October 1993 until September 2011 & now lives on in digital form as We cover everything to do with SA fine wine.