Michael Fridjhon: Is there a difference between authentic wine vs wine made to taste expensive?

Testalonga El Bandito 2016

“Nerdy” wine?

What makes a wine “nerdy” – and for that matter, are these the same features which communicate authenticity? I recently – somewhat frivolously – wrote that “if you fancy yourself a wine geek, you dare not mention that you drank – let alone enjoyed – a bottle of Nederburg or even Diemersdal. You’re not supposed to mention anything produced outside the Swartland and in volumes exceeding the contents of a 228 litre barrel.” As for authenticity, Christian Eedes once suggested (also, possibly, a little frivolously if not controversially) that the aesthetic of genuine or craft wines did not include the concept of “smoothness.” He was, I think, implying that there was something “fake” about the opulent mouthfeel of wines which were clearly made to taste expensive.

It’s easy enough to shoot down both these positions: there are geeky wines coming from sites in the Klein Karoo. Likewise it’s hard to argue that a bottle of Romanee-Conti isn’t authentic, but that doesn’t mean that it’s not polished. However, when it comes to what we in South Africa think of as geeky, genuine, off-the-beaten track, we half expect that such wines must display rustic elements – whether in terms of texture (not so smooth), colour (oxidised hues) or aromatics (earthy whiffs). This also doesn’t stand serious scrutiny. Most highly regarded producers are hugely competent winemakers. You don’t expect a wine from Eben Sadie, Andrea Mullineux or the Alheits to be anything except perfectly assembled. To the extent that they have tannins on display, they would be in balance with all the other flavour and textural elements and appropriate in terms of the age of the wine.

But this is not the end of the debate: the more geeky wine aficionados would probably argue that the Sadies and Alheits are now pretty much mainstream. They’ve been around for some years, they run real wine enterprises, they have mailing lists, they undertake international shows – they may be smaller than, for example, Jordan or Cederberg, but they are hardly fringe.

This raises the less easily resolved question of what would constitute edgy in the minds of this slightly ill-defined group of wine lovers. Are they ultra-boutique and undiscovered, but potentially the next generation of Adi Badenhorsts and Mullineuxs? Are they financially marginal – and is this part of their appeal? Is the association with authenticity and the absence of polish really one of artisanal (and slightly unscientific) hand-craftedness? A barrel here, a cement egg there, all left to ferment “naturally” (naturally), free of pre-fermentation “adjustments” and with little or no sulphur added, even at bottling. In this event, Eedes’s “smoothness” is a kind of portmanteau term for evidence of technical competence – and the case against it is that it may have been achieved at the price of the unmediated expression of site.

If this is the case, I’m not sure that – to paraphrase Bertrand Russell – the open mind here is anything other than the empty mind. Those who believe that any intervention, from the judicious use of sulphur to flavour-neutral cultured natural yeasts, comes between the terroir and the consumer, find themselves in the reductio ad absurdum of having to accept that all forms of oxidation are desirable because they are an expression of the natural propensity of wine to turn to vinegar over time. The late Henri Jayer “discovered” a site in Vosne Romanee which earlier generations had largely disregarded, and in one lifetime, in an area already better mapped out than almost any other viticultural region in the world, lifted Cros Parantoux to much the same status as Romanee-Conti. He didn’t do this by allowing shabby winemaking to mask the precision of site: on the contrary, he coaxed from the grapes wines of extraordinary purity, expressions of place that elevated the perception of their pedigree.

There’s no easy resolution to these genuinely contradictory positions. Authenticity does require unmediated expression of site, but the wine must still have the potential to evolve if it is to achieve its fullest potential – and that means that it can’t begin life at the edge of a precipitate decline. I think sometimes we allow the pursuit of edginess to get the better of our judgement. This may not be a uniquely South African affliction, but we encounter it more frequently, possibly because our industry was constrained for so long by the dead hand of authority and by the aesthetic demands of the co-ops and the big wholesalers who determined what landed up on the wine shop shelves. If this assumption is correct, we’ll discover that the new vistas we now stumble across are not some undiscovered land but what would always have been there for us to see if our vision had not been blinkered by our past.

  • Michael Fridjhon has over thirty-five years’ experience in the liquor industry. He is founder of Winewizard.co.za and holds various positions including: Visiting Professor of Wine Business at the University of Cape Town; founder and director of WineX – the largest consumer wine show in the Southern Hemisphere and chairman of The Old Mutual Trophy Wine Show.

Tagged

Share this post

3 Comments

  1. Kevin RApril 27, 2017 at 11:09 pmReply

    It’s interesting to see a couple of producers making wines as a nod to the past, such as Richesse and Leeu Passant red. These will likely succeed as they offer some of the best elements of bye gone styles with a modern twist. On another point many estates are now producing world class wines – could style be the factor that differentiates which estates are, and which estates aren’t, seen as producing investment worthy wines in the eyes of the next generation of consumers who aren’t sentimental about the leading estates of today or yesteryear? I believe it will. Tired, dry tannins seem to be falling out of fashion at a rapid pace and the varietal which each wine is composed of seems to be diminishing in importance, still relevant but less so than ever before as style is playing a greater role than it ever has.

  2. ChristianApril 27, 2017 at 10:05 pmReply

    Hi Smirrie, No dig at Craig Hawkins. Happen to be a fan but I wouldn’t call any of his wines “smooth”.

  3. SmirrieApril 27, 2017 at 2:23 pmReply

    What is the relevance of the specific photo used with the article.

    Is there any supposed dig at Craig Hawkins or not ?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

SHOP ONLINE
winemag-storm
ADVERTISING
ADVERTISING
HOT AND HAPPENING
AEC v1.0.4
  • No upcoming events
AEC v1.0.4
ADVERTISING
newlstter2 Get the biggest stories of the past fortnight sent directly to your inbox. subscribe
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
ADVERTISING
BE SAFE

Wine magazine was published from October 1993 until September 2011 & now lives on in digital form as Winemag.co.za. We cover everything to do with SA fine wine.

XSLT Plugin by Leo Jiang