Platter’s 2018 – trying to be all things to all people?

November 8, 2017
by Christian
in Opinion & Analysis
with 5 Comments

Platter's SA Wine Guide 2018So the 2018 edition of Platter’s South African Wine Guide is out – 111 wines out of over 8 000 wines featured rating 5 Stars (see here). Isn’t that rather a lot of 5 Star wines, you might ask? Well, it’s a 429% increase on the 21 wines that managed the guide’s ultimate accolade in 2008 but it’s not as many as the 149 wines (out of some 1 700 reviewed in total) to score 95 points or higher on the 100-point quality scale that Tim Atkin had in his South Africa Special Report released earlier this year.

In the lead-up to this year’s launch, Platter’s made something of a fuss about the fact that for the first time ever, bottle stickers with the ratings on the 100-point scale would be available – individual Platter’s tasters use the 100-point system when making their initial sighted assessments, all wines scoring 90 points or higher going into a second round of tasting conducted blind, the final score then converted into a star rating.

Platter’s justifies having both Stars and scores available in that the former has more resonance locally and the latter more internationally. Whatever the case, it would be fascinating to know what the guide did in fact score Magnetic North Mountain Makstok 2016 and Radio Lazarus 2016 from Alheit Vineyards or Family Vineyards Pinot Noir 2016 from Newton Johnson, all three left on 4.5 stars. Conversely, there were no 100-pointers or we would’ve already heard…

Turns out, however, that those scores on the 100-point scale are only available if you take out a digital subscription with the ink-on-paper, physical guide still making reference only to star ratings. The guide itself costs R260 a copy while the one-year digital subscription costs R175 and provides access to all ratings and reviews since 2008 through the website and apps. This makes digital looks like a pretty good deal until you get to the Google Play Store to discover that the Platter’s app has an average rating of 1.9 out of a possible 5 (after 29 reviews) which makes me, at least, reluctant to download.

More generally, though, that list of 111 wines rated 5 Stars is pretty respectable. Reviews and rankings are necessarily approximate but not entirely useless – it is only natural that producers should seek recognition for their endeavor and it is equally only natural that consumers should want assistance in making their purchasing decision when confronted by a hugely over-traded market.

Platter’s is a noble undertaking and remains influential although I’m not sure it’s status as the “bible” of SA wine as somebody referred to it on Twitter recently is still warranted. The South African wine industry has become too fluid and dynamic, the debate about what’s hot and what’s not too fast moving for an annual old-media publication to be the first and last word on the matter. Clearly the brains trust behind it is wrestling with new media options but will they succeed?

Tagged

Share this post

5 Comments

  1. David ClarkeNovember 13, 2017 at 8:20 amReply

    Just a short note to say that Platter’s still sells more wine (in SA) than any other competition/guide/award.

  2. Tim AtkinNovember 9, 2017 at 9:07 pmReply

    The Mount Bullet Merlot is listed twice. The PDF will be updated later tonight to correct the mistake. Thanks for pointing it out.

  3. Tim AtkinNovember 9, 2017 at 3:47 pmReply

    Thanks for the correction. Will change the PDF. Vintages of Raats in the main report.

  4. Tim AtkinNovember 9, 2017 at 8:27 amReply

    Readers of Wine Magazine might be interested to see my Wines of the Year, which I have now extracted from my site and made available as a free download. Interesting to compare and contrast them with the Platter Five Stars. We agree on a few wines, but differ on the majority, I think that’s a good thing, as it helps to promote the diversity of the SA wine industry. http://www.timatkin.com/reports/2017-south-africa-wines-year

    • KwispedoorNovember 9, 2017 at 10:08 amReply

      Thanks for the interesting report, Tim. There’s a little mistake there with Shannon’s Mount Bullet being listed under the Pinots. Was the entire line a mistake or did you mean to include Shannon’s Pinot there?

      I’m not sure what vintage of Raats Cabernet Franc you’ve tasted, but – looking at both the excellent 2014 and 2015 vintages of the wine – I’m surprised not to see it included under the Cab Franc section.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

SHOP ONLINE
winemag-storm
ADVERTISING
ADVERTISING
HOT AND HAPPENING
AEC v1.0.4
  • November 23, 2017FNB Eastern Cape Wine Show
  • November 29, 2017Stellenbosch at Summer Place - presented by Sanlam Private Wealth
AEC v1.0.4
ADVERTISING
newlstter2 Get the biggest stories of the past fortnight sent directly to your inbox. subscribe
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
ADVERTISING
BE SAFE

Wine magazine was published from October 1993 until September 2011 & now lives on in digital form as Winemag.co.za. We cover everything to do with SA fine wine.

XSLT Plugin by Leo Jiang