Tim James: The Swartland Independent Wyn, Kos en Kultuur Skou 2015 reviewed

April 27, 2015
by Tim James
in Opinion & Analysis
with 5 Comments

The Swartland Independent Producers were strutting their stuff in Riebeek-Kasteel last Saturday – and a great show it was. They drifted into Afrikaans and called it the “Wyn, kos en kultuur skou”. As to the elements in the name, apart from the almost universally excellent wine, the food seemed to be a monopoly of extremely expensive meat rolls (no doubt good, but when I went to get one there was a promised 10-minute delay, so I popped round the corner to PicknPay for some “pizza”, which was much cheaper, tasty enough and usefully mopped up some of the chenin and syrah). Culture consisted, first, of a gentle old-fashioned bunch of people singing and dancing (and providing some respite from the overwhelming whiteness of the winemakers and wine-drinkers); then later some decidedly ungentle rock music played off the back of a truck.

Adie Badenhorst of AA Badenhorst Family Wines.

Adie Badenhorst of AA Badenhorst Family Wines.

And I suppose you might add to the cultural side of things that Adi Badenhorst’s luxurious beard is helping him look worryingly like Rosa Kruger’s great-great-etc grandfather, Paul.

Previous SIP showings have been held at the annual Swartland Revolution, but it’s a good thing that the tasting has broken away – not least because the shared occasion wasn’t helping people understand the difference between the two. In case you’re among the continuing confused, Swartland Revolution is an event organised by just four wineries (Sadie, Mullineux, Badenhorst and Porseleinberg), while the SIP organisation is open to all Swartland producers, whose qualifying wines must observe appellation-type rules regarding origin, natural fermention, restricted oaking, permitted grape varieties, etc (see more about it all here). Actually it would probably have been a good idea for the organisers of this event to have taken the trouble to have some information about SIP on display, or available – I’d bet a great many people attending were not properly aware of the significance of the organisation.

Back in 2011 when SIP was founded, there were about a dozen members; on Saturday twice as many took part, ranging from large estates like Lammershoek to small set-ups like that of Jasper Wickens, whose day job sees him making wine for Badenhorst. Interestingly, two other small but now-independent wineries are owned by men who were previously assistant winemakers in the Swartland: Bryan MacRobert (Bryan was once at Sadie) and Intellego – Jurgen Gouws, formerly of Lammershoek. Testalonga is in a sense another breakaway from Lammershoek, the project of former winemaker Craig Hawkins and former sales and marketing manager Carla Kretzel. The great news is that Testalonga will shortly be getting a permanent (northerly) Swartland home, when it moves onto a farm near Piekenierskloof.

The strange absence from the SIP show was the winery which, I’d guess, most people would most immediately associate with the new Swartland: Sadie Family Wines. Eben was there with the forthcoming pair under his Sequillo label (the red breathtakingly sophisticated and lovely, the white not quite up to that level, I thought), but for some reason doesn’t want his qualifying Sadie Family bottlings to bear the SIP logo. That seems a great pity to me, weakening the brand.

Not that the whole project is significantly undermined. The other great names of the modern and exciting Swartland were present and immensely correct: Mullineux Family (they’ll have to forgive me for not easily believing in something called the Mullineux and Leeu Family, however hard I swallow); Porseleinberg (looks like the 2011 will not be properly released, though some bottles will be available to “collectors; the 2013 looking just fine); Badenhorst (Oom-Paulish Adi as brilliantly innovative and interesting as ever with his lovely dry muscat bottling for the CWG auction and the fascinating cinsaut-like red from barbarossa – whatever that might be, and even Jancis Robinson seems unsure – up the West Coast); David (the other Sadie, his wines as quiet and authoritatively convincing as ever).

And new, emerging stars. At whose head I reckon will be (judging by present performance) Jasper Wickens, whose piercingly fine red and white Swerwer wines are just about as good and exciting as any to be had in the Swartland.

  • Tim James is founder of Grape.co.za and contributes to various local and international wine publications. He is a taster (and associate editor) for Platter’s. His book Wines of South Africa – Tradition and Revolution appeared in 2013.

Tagged , , , , , , , , ,

Share this post


  1. Hennie TaljaardApril 22, 2016 at 9:48 amReply

    Malmesbury definitely the better venue with lots more space, parking, toilets, added activities and child friendly. Malmesbury is also the capital of the Swartland! Long live the SIP!

  2. SmirrieApril 22, 2016 at 9:05 amReply

    If the reference is indeed to Eben it is of utmost importance to note that his Sequillo wines was the only Eben Sadie Wines always bearing the SIP sticker.

    Furthermore i am sure that a pioneer or as they erstwhile called themselves revolutionaries he is still actively involved in promoting the region.

    I didn’t see the poster so i cant comment on a possible allegation of false advertising.

    I also miss the whole vibe of Riebeek-Kasteel and the legendary Swartland Revolution Weekends but if the region wish to become more important and not only hipster they need to showcase their wines to a broader crowd.

    That is my humble opinion.

  3. Ingrid Reid AndrewsApril 19, 2016 at 5:41 pmReply

    Assuming this article refers to the April 2, 2016 tasting in Malmesbury, the SIPs website & R250 passport, promised tastings from 25 Swartland Independent Producers.
    As loyal supporters of independent Winemakers in the Swartland, we were disappointed that one of the flagships, did not even have a stand at the last show.
    Regardless of whether they had samples of wine for tasting or not, the lack of apology on the day, for not delivering on the advertised tastings, or even having someone to represent the brand and its success, was very disappointing.
    For what it is worth to the respective brand ambassadors under the SIPs umbrella, as well as those following your wine-making creativity, there is a feeling amongst some ‘prosumers’ that the last Tasting Event contributed little to the future brand equity of the SIPs Brand as we know it.
    Please bring the tasting Event back to Short Street in Riebeek Kasteel where the Revolutiion started for many of us – or have you forgotten?
    Ingrid Reid Andrews

    • SamanthaApril 20, 2016 at 6:30 pmReply

      Ingrid, as per the date on the article it refers to the SIP SKOU of 2015 on Short Street.
      Whilst the Short Street venue is quaint it can’t service the amount of people who attend the show anymore – the space in Malmesbury allows for food stalls, a wine bar, games on the lawn etc. We also want to show that the Swartland is not “just” Riebeek Kasteel.

      Out of interest who was the “flagship winery” not there? All wineries who were advertised on the poster were in attendance and pouring their wines.

      Adi Badenhorst, Mullineuxs and Porseleinberg were all there…. if you are referring to Eben Sadie he chooses not to be a member of the Swartland Independent as a lot of his wines come from various regions (Mev Kirsten from Stellenbosch for example). But if you are not talking about Eben I would like to hear your thoughts?

      Whilst there is always room for improvement on any event we SIP members were very happy with the venue, food, music and wines on offer for the day and heard nothing but good feedback but constructive criticism is always welcome… I am still confused who you were expecting an apology from though :-)

  4. Hennie TaljaardApril 27, 2015 at 1:30 pmReply

    I thought the Rall Red 2013 was classy and outstanding. But for me the Swerwer red 2014 was the best of the tasting.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


AEC v1.0.4
  • October 26, 2016RMB WineX 2016
  • October 29, 2016Season of Sauvignon Festival
  • November 1, 2016Prescient Chardonnay Public Tasting - Café Cru, Monte Casino
  • November 2, 2016Presecient Chardonnay Public Tasting - Protea Hotel Fire&Ice!
AEC v1.0.4
newlstter2 Get the biggest stories of the past fortnight sent directly to your inbox. subscribe

Wine magazine was published from October 1993 until September 2011 & now lives on in digital form as Winemag.co.za. We cover everything to do with South African wine.

XSLT Plugin by Leo Jiang