| SA Wine Ratings, News, Opinion & Analysis

Tim James: Wine – the stuff of love and soil

November 16, 2015
by Tim James
in Opinion & Analysis
with 3 Comments
Adi Badenhorst and Callie Louw in action at the Swartland Revolution.

Adi Badenhorst and Callie Louw in action at the Swartland Revolution.

Two responses to my last week’s piece on the Swartland Revolution made particular sense to me. Though they were essentially antithetical, having to resolve the contradiction recalled to me an essential significance of wine in modern life.

The first response came in an email from someone fully involved in the wine industry who commented, having said how much the event had been enjoyed (again): “If I’m paying R3000 per person I want better wines than was offered this year”. And it’s true that the revolution is expensive (though is costly to put on, and seldom breaks even), and also true that, unlike the great show of international wines put on last year, this year’s wines were comparatively modest (and the Californian ones were donated, though freighting them in wasn’t). As my not-rich correspondent said, when you think of the food and wine the ticket price could have bought elsewhere, “R3K for young vine cinsault…”.

That young-vine cinsaut, with young-vine grenache and young-vine agiorgitiko came in the “Swartland Secrets” tasting of experimental or sideline wines made by the Revolutionaries. It was this tasting that was named as a highlight by a hugely enthusiastic first-time visitor to the Revolution, Ankia Pelser, in an online comment to my blog. Ankia didn’t go into much detail, but said: “I enjoyed the passion that was portrayed – from the winemakers and from the wine-drinkers alike.”

That’s it, I think, the basic reason for the success of the Swartland Revolution. It offers, and this also applies to events like the Young Guns tasting put on by Wine cellar each year, a chance for people to get further in touch with one of the real marvels of the life of wine: that it is one of the things most resistant (though far from immune) to the deadening estrangement from the sources of much of our sensual lives. It is the stuff of love and soil, not just of accountants and marketing strategies

As consumers, we seem to be surrounded by choice, within the limits of what we can afford, but are we really? Supermarkets, the most implacable face of consumerism, succeed in controlling our choices down to a few possibilities in most things: a few variants in yoghurt, tomato sauce and washing powder, etc. But move to the wine section, and the brand possibilities explode: even if a few big ones are comparatively dominant – there’s no comparison to the choice of cooldrinks or (dare I say?) whisky.

This genuine choice is a triumph that we must strive to hold on to, before wine goes the way of so much else agricultural. And the choice reflects the nature of production of wine: not, for the most part, huge, capital-intensive concerns, but small-scale activities, with real people – farmers and wine-makers – making choices, caring about what they do and why, and seeing the process through from beginning to end. I think all real wine-lovers experience wine in this larger way, as a link to something we have mostly lost, but retain a dim sense of, in our so-directed lives.

Those of us – like my email correspondent – who move amongst those who work in the vineyards and cellars can sometimes forget what a privilege it is, and take it for granted. For us, rare and costly wines to taste are more important at an event like the Swartland Revolution, and that is fine and correct. But I’m reminded what a real thrill it is to get involved in the whole story. And, incidentally, what a limited approach it is to regard wine as just that liquid in the bottle, to be rated in abstract.

We need more public wine festivals; it would be good for wine in every respect.

  • Tim James is founder of and contributes to various local and international wine publications. He is a taster (and associate editor) for Platter’s. His book Wines of South Africa – Tradition and Revolution appeared in 2013.

Tagged ,

Share this post


  1. Tom PriorNovember 16, 2015 at 5:16 pmReply

    I was feeling a little too poorly to properly enjoy the wines poured at this 9am tasting…
    That said, of the weekend seminars it was my favourite. Particularly Eben’s chat about the diversity and importance of new cultivars coming into SA. The chat on Semillon Gris… a view from the point of the grape farmer.
    You got a real sense for the Swartland revs not only working in the now, but for the industry 20 years from now. It was exciting stuff and for the wine geek, there was a lot of good talking points to raise with mates down the local wine boozer.
    It was also quite a sight seeing the bins of pretty pricey Swartland wines (generously enjoyed between and after the seminars) being cleared on the final afternoon, whist rubbing shoulders with those who make them. You can’t put a price on that.

  2. SmirrieNovember 16, 2015 at 4:19 pmReply

    I was fortunate to attend the festival for my third time. Like previously i did enjoy it immensely. We were a group of 10 people who has flown down from Pretoria to attend and have fun. In our group i am perhaps the most avid wine drinker and have the privilege to taste many wines and purchase a lot from the new wave winemakers.

    I personally was a bit disappointed in the 11h00. My kind of Wine tasting and would rather have preferred to taste something unknown to me or international. However many of my friends including Ankia Pelser really enjoyed that tasting. I must admit the fact that most of those winemakers was in the crowd made up for the fact that we tasted wine known to most of our regular wine purchasers.

    The wines of PAX was interesting and one of the readers i attend the revolution and happily fork out the money for tickets, accommodation and flights. The 09h00 tasting was important to experience of how will they take the lead (tongue in the cheek) even further.

    And we must compliment the organizers for the fantastic food. The best of all the years perhaps.

  3. James MoffettNovember 16, 2015 at 12:43 pmReply

    Enjoyed that Tim.
    Living in the Free State, I envy those who live in reasonable proximity to the Revolutionaries and their waves of change, able to see first-hand action and taste the change. That was until recently, when The Bald Ibis winery released its first vintage- the Altitude Collection, between Fouriesburg and Clarens and within spitting distance of my farm, where I had the privilege of experiencing a highland revolution (without spitting) of Pinot, Shiraz and Pinotage made by maverick John Critchly, who ignored all naysayers in his quest to dream an impossible dream. Using natural vineyard management and gentle cellar handling, he has produced wines of unique style, yet delicious and deep coloured, particularly the Pinot. So, in short, I do not envy you in the Cape as much, but encourage you to try the Bald Ibis Revolutionary. All the best, James

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


thirteen + six =

AEC v1.0.4
  • December 5, 2015Franschhoek ‘Magic of Bubbles’ Cap Classique and Champagne Festival
AEC v1.0.4
SA Blog Awards
SA Blog Awards Badge
newlstter2 Get the biggest stories of the past fortnight sent directly to your inbox. subscribe
Wine magazine was published from October 1993 until September 2011 and now lives on in digital form as We cover everything to do with South African wine.
XSLT Plugin by Leo Jiang