Patapon 2009

By , 21 January 2013



Clowning around.

Over the weekend such natural wines as Domaine le Briseau Patapon Coteaux du Loir 2009. From the Pineau d’Aunis variety, it was rustic, dirty even, but wonderfully so. Craig Hawkins of Lammershoek in the Swartland in South Africa and his Testalonga El Bandito 2009, Testalonga El Bandito Cortex 2011 and Cellar Foot Harslevelu 2010 also featured.

So what exactly is natural wine? It’s a highly controversial term but broadly equates to “nothing added, nothing taken away”. This entails producers following organic or biodynamic viticultural practices, whether certified or not, while in the cellar additives are restricted – no cultured yeasts and absolutely minimal amounts of sulphur allowed.

Proponents of natural wine tend towards anarchy in the true sense and there’s a deliberate resistance to any regulation. Just how much of a political agenda is there behind the movement? It most definitely can be seen as a reaction to conventional wine, which natural wine advocates argue is overly commercial and joyless. More specifically, a large part of wine’s appeal is due to its diversity but it has become more and more homogenised due to the use of technology – natural wine seeks to ensure that wine retains its sense of place.

What natural wine represents is a counter-point to wines made with a large degree of technological intervention, including processes like yeasting, acidification or chapitalisation, reverse osmosis or micro-oxygenation. While not exclusive to natural wine movement, the increasing shift away from barrique as a vessel for fermentation and maturation towards large-format, old-wood vats, concrete and amphorae is very much in line with its values. It might even be said that natural wine proponents have introduced another colour of wine – no longer only red, white and rosé but orange (on account of the oxidation which inevitably occurs).

Seemingly lots to like about natural wine but it’s currently generating some of the most heated debates in wine circles. First and foremost, natural wines often have very unusual flavour profiles – because of the way they are made they are prone to flaws and faults such as oxidation and the effects of spoilage yeast Brettanomyces. The debate then becomes when are these characteristics adding interest to a wine and when are they simply dominating the wine detracting from basic quality and over-riding any sense of place. Natural wine advocates will typically argue that to fixate on flaws and faults is to be trapped in a paradigm where wines are either “correct” or “incorrect”.

More generally, natural wine receives criticism for being either too vague or too idealistic. Too vague in the sense that without formal definition, it cannot be properly policed allowing producers who aren’t true to the cause to claim natural wine credentials. Equally, producers certified organic are worried that ‘natural’ wines might be confused with ‘organic’ wines and might harm their improving reputation, as organic wine producers have been driving up standards for over 20 years whereas natural wines have only recently come to prominence.

The argument that natural wine is too idealistic simply comes stems from the observation that  literally speaking there can be no ‘natural wine’ because wine doesn’t exist in nature. Without human input, fermented grape juice tends to vinegar.

Perhaps not everything about natural wine adds up but ask yourself this: why are food, but not wine, producers compelled to supply ingredient labelling? The level of additives in most wines is probably higher than it need be and if natural wine ends up forcing producers to use a lighter hand in this regard, so much the better.


5 comment(s)

  • Kwispedoor22 January 2013

    Quite a few of our natural winemakers are starting to pick when their grapes are ripe, instead of over-ripe, which generally means a lower pH. Brett doesn’t like low pH so – coupled with a few other good wine making techniques – this bodes well for general “cleanliness” of natural wines. The role of SO2 is substantial and far-reaching though, so natural winemakers that make wine that is structured to come into its own with some maturation, might be well-advised to not be too skimpy on the SO2. But yes, only time will provide more definitive answers. 

  • Angela Lloyd21 January 2013

    ‘because of the way they are made they are prone to flaws and faults such as oxidation and the effects of spoilage yeast Brettanomyces.’
    Christian, surely these faults aren’t exclusive nor even more prone to natural wine. In the hands of a good winemaker, whether following natural or conventional approach, there are less likely to be such faults than if the winemaker is less than assiduous in his/her attention to the wine. There are horrors both sides of the fence.
    What we have yet to see is how well these local natural wines fare with ageing.

  • Samantha21 January 2013

    I drank an interesting natural wine last week – Sebastien Riffault Auksinis Sancerre 2007. Whilst certainly individual and unusual, I felt that the almost ‘lack of wine making’ had destroyed the Sauvignon Blanc and regional /terroir characteristics. I was posed with the thought – when does natural wine-making actually start to take away from the flavours of the grape that you harvest in the first place? I do not believe in reverse osmosis, added yeasts etc but I feel a happy balance can be derived between the two. The wine for example would have just benefited from SO2 to keep it tight and fresh, and enabled it to age – instead it was oxidized, flabby and within 4 hours tasted completely (not in a good way) different from when we first opened the bottle.

  • Christian21 January 2013

    Wines were drunk at dinners after Wine Tasting Academy classes and served to provoke discussion so apologies for the lack of tasting notes. Suffice to say, I generally get great enjoyment out of natural wines (they fundamentally appeal to my anti-establishment disposition) but am not at all convinced they are moire true to place than conventional wines. To quote a recent tweet from Bonny Doon’s Randall Grahm, “vin orange often overly stylized & can obscure [rather than illuminate] distinctive qualities of terroir”.

  • Rihann21 January 2013

    Interesting!  No tasting notes??  I had an experience recently when importing 100% sparkling grape juice to China.  Every iota of the juice had to be shown on the chemical analysis while with the wines they were happy with “XXX grape variety, contains sulphites”.  I suppose it adds to the mystery/romance of wine BUT in countries where wine is not very strictly regulated, you can pretty much add whatever you want to get a certain taste and show none of it on the label.  

    Also interesting that juice gets rejected if the levels of sulphur are over 35mg/l whereas there is no such cap on wine.  The problem with the juice is that it reduces the shelf life to one year in stead of two years.

Leave a Reply to Kwispedoor Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Like our content?

Show your support.