SA 2005 under review

April 20, 2015
by Christian Eedes
in Opinion & Analysis
with 4 Comments
Image courtesy of

Image courtesy of

Recently a tasting of 12 wines from the 2005 vintage courtesy of colleague Angela Lloyd (read her report here). Three flights of four as follows: Flight One – Vergelegen White, Boekenhoutskloof Semillon, Hamilton Russell Vineyards Chardonnay and Hartenberg Riesling; Flight Two – Hartenberg Gravel Hill Shiraz, Quoin Rock Syrah, Waterford CWG Reserve and Waterford The Jem; and Flight Three – Vergelegen Cabernet Franc Merlot, Vilafonté Series C, Thelema Cabernet Sauvignon and Boekenhoutskloof Cabernet Sauvignon.

Sadly, I was left underwhelmed. All the whites were in decline if not undrinkable – tasting blind, my favourite wine (with a score of 90/100) was the Hartenberg but I wasn’t confident that it was a Riesling – there was lots about it that suggested “exotic white blend” – and no doubt the 18g/l RS had helped preserve it and probably still adds to its appeal.

As for the reds, they were all more or less hanging on but few if any at all have become more complex or interesting by virtue of bottle maturation. Stellenbosch was, according to most sources, hot, dry and early and the wines from here and environs are typically super-concentrated.

My favourite wine of the day was The Jem from Waterford (58% Cabernet Sauvignon, 12% Shiraz, 11% Mourvèdre, 7% Malbec, 7% Merlot, 2% Sangiovese and 3% Barbera.). Red and black fruit with some floral perfume. Relatively medium bodied with freshness and fine tannins. Good fruit purity and great length. Still very much alive and I gave it an upbeat score of 94/100.

All very humbling as I think I was alone among the eight tasters gathered in feeling enthusiastic about this wine. Moreover, when I had the 2005, 2007 and 2009 of The Jem next to each other back in mid-2013, I said it had “rustic appeal” and gave it a score of 88/100 (see here). What was particularly mortifying this time around is that the wine came after the Waterford Auction Reserve (80% Cabernet Sauvignon, 10% Merlot and 10% Malbec) which as recently as February of this year, I rated 95/100 (see here).

Context matters so much when it comes to wine tasting and side by side on this particular day, the Cab-driven Auction Reserve looked very “green” next to multi-variety The Jem. You live, you learn.

Tagged , ,

Share this post


  1. Hennie LouwMay 18, 2015 at 9:46 amReply

    Yesterday we had the pleasure to drink a De Toren Fusion 5 2005. Slightly bricky in colour, but still very drinkable. Little bit leaner than I expected. Still enough fruit to enjoy. Altogether a good experience.

  2. Dieter GugelmannApril 21, 2015 at 3:51 pmReply

    I’m still drinking the Mulderbosch Chardonnay 2005 100% Barrel fermented. Mike Dobrovic did a very good Job. The wine is still great. No signs off beeing tired. I’m sad, only one bottle left!!!

    • Christian EedesApril 21, 2015 at 4:47 pmReplyAuthor

      Hi Dieter, I was at a dinner party hosted by my friend and colleague James Pietersen about six weeks ago where the Mulderbosch BF 2005 was shown next to Ataraxia 2005 and Uva Mira 2005 – all the wines showed very well, the Uva Mira in particular, once again suggesting that this is a property to watch. My sense about the Hamilton Russell Vineyards mentioned in the main post was that it suffered from random bottle oxidation (I’ve had the wine recently and I remember it being in much better shape). Suffice to say, I think Chardonnay is probably as age-worthy as anything that SA does, white or red.

  3. Nadine RoetsApril 21, 2015 at 2:33 pmReply

    Recently I’ve had great comments about a couple of 2005 magnums that our clients drank recently. Would be interesting to have a tasting comparing the same wines, 750ml vs. 1.5l and seeing how ageability differs in the 2 formats.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


AEC v1.0.4
  • October 26, 2016RMB WineX 2016
  • October 29, 2016Season of Sauvignon Festival
  • November 1, 2016Prescient Chardonnay Public Tasting - Café Cru, Monte Casino
  • November 2, 2016Presecient Chardonnay Public Tasting - Protea Hotel Fire&Ice!
AEC v1.0.4
newlstter2 Get the biggest stories of the past fortnight sent directly to your inbox. subscribe

Wine magazine was published from October 1993 until September 2011 & now lives on in digital form as We cover everything to do with South African wine.

XSLT Plugin by Leo Jiang