Home // News

Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report 2018

By , 12 September 2018



Tim Atkin SA Special Report 2018The sixth annual Tim Atkin South Africa Special Report is now out, the British journalist and Master of Wine awarding his first ever 100-point score in the New World to the Kanonkop Paul Sauer 2015 and 99 points to two whites: Alheit Vineyards Magnetic North 2017 and Sadie Family ’T Voetpad 2017.

Special acknowledgements as follows:

Winemaker of the Year: Chris Alheit of Alheit Vineyards
Young Winemaker of the Year: Lukas van Loggerenberg of Van Loggerenberg Wines
Grower of the Year: Basie van Lill
Co-operative of the Year: Klawer Cellars
Winemaking Legend: Jan Boland Coetzee of Vriesenhof
Overall White Wine of the Year: Sadie Family ’T Voetpad 2017
Overall Red Wine of the Year: Kanonkop Paul Sauer 2015
Overall Rosé of the Year: Raised by Wolves Newlands Pinot Meunier 2017
Overall Sparkling Wine of the Year: Le Lude Magnum Vintage Cuvée 2012
Overall Sweet Wine of the Year: Klein Constantia Vin de Constance 2015
Overall Fortified Wine of the Year: De Krans Cape Vintage Reserve 2016
Red Wine Discovery of the Year: Rall Ava Syrah 2017
White Wine Discovery of the Year: Alheit Huilkrans 2017
Best Value White of the Year: Stellenrust Chenin Blanc 2018
Best Value Red of the Year: Zonnebloem SMV 2016
Best Value Rosé of the Year: Oude Kompagnies Post Swanepoel Rosé 2018
Best Value Sparkling Wine of the Year: Villiera Tradition Brut NV
Best Value Sweet Wine of the Year: Namaqua Noble Late Harvest 2013
Best Value Fortified Wine of the Year: Du Toitskloof Red Muscadel 2015

The report costs R395 and is available for download here.


5 comment(s)

Please read our Comments Policy here.

    Greg Haigh | 14 September 2018

    I understand he said in interview, yesterday, that it was somewhat of a reaction to Wine Spectator awarding some exorbitant number of 100’s to Aussie wines over the years. Basically saying it’s bull and that this wine is at least equivalent to those, and that it’s about time we started seeing some SA wines getting full marks in the press.

    Kevin R | 13 September 2018

    If Tim Atkin feels he will never come across better, no problem and huge congrats Kanonkop. Hennie I think it needs to come down to the wine in the glass, not the theory of Producer+Vintage=Must be maximum.

    In my opinion, 100/100 is reserved for a wine that you are confident you’ll never taste better; on par – fine, but no other wine you come across in future can be better otherwise your scoring was incorrect. Big feather in Kanonkop’s cap.

    Hennie Taljaard | 13 September 2018

    I just wonder whether the producer and vintage does not oblige this perfect score. because if you are not going to score arguably the most iconic SA wine from the most iconic estate and from the most praised vintage a perfect 100, when will you ever? and the critic to be the first to do that also gets to win the scoring race. I have tasted the 2015 Sauer, it is very good, but if it is worth 100 points then there are quite a couple of other wines worthy of the same score.

    Dionysus | 12 September 2018

    Dear Christian
    Thanks for this. But how about a bit of journalism as opposed to PR cut and paste job. I would like to know your thoughts opinions etc on Tim’s report. The scores are high, certainly a point or two across the board higher than your own. Paul Sauer you scored 94 points, he 100 points, that is a 6 point spread. Tim clearly thinks it is a world class wine. Please shed some light. As South Africa’s leading wine commentator I am always interested in your local take on things.
    Regards Dionysus

      Christian Eedes | 13 September 2018

      Hi Dionysus, Essentially, I think the report is all grist to the mill – the more high-profile international commentators taking a keen interest in South African fine wine, the better for the industry. As for the differential between my score and Tim’s for the Kanonkop Paul Sauer 2015, I’m not sure I can add much insight – I liked it and he liked it even more. I would contend that 94/100 does indicate a “world-class” wine while 100/100 indicates “perfection” which, in the context of all human endeavour and considering the concept in a philosophical light, is not readily attained.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Like our content?

Show your support.