Michael Fridjhon: Apocalypse now – SA wine in crisis

By , 14 January 2021



Harvest 2021 is coming… Image: Tokara.

The 2021 vintage looms while South Africa’s third prohibition in less than 10 months shuts off the supply of wines, spirits, beers and liqueurs to the entire (legal) market. With over 250 000 jobs in the wine industry and upwards of 800 000 in the hospitality sector now all under pressure, it’s not callous to question the rationality of the government’s response to the post-holiday season spike in infections. It’s hard to avoid the conclusion that the ANC is more concerned with driving an anti-alcohol agenda than applying a more sophisticated and segmented approach which would manage risk while sustaining economic activity.

It’s also safe to assume that if it’s willing to sacrifice the rank-and-file employees of the hospitality sector, then it’s not likely to consider the impact of the lockdown on vineyard owners. After the end of the last lockdown, the predictions suggested that there would be an unsold inventory of close to 300m litres of wine by the time we went into the 2021 harvest. Even if this figure is exaggerated, even if exports have siphoned up some of this bulk, even if this latest prohibition doesn’t add significantly to the overfull pipeline (all quite dangerous assumptions, but worth entertaining) we are looking at a catastrophe for many of the country’s 2 750 grape farmers.

It’s worth reviewing their predicament before the horror of 2020. In 2019 exports dropped by 24% compared with 2018; domestic wine sales were down 7%. In one year, from 2018 to 2019, 10% of their number abandoned grape growing. As recently as 2010 there were over 3 500 of them. However, while their numbers decline, the total size of the SA grape crop has remained pretty fixed (except for the worst of the drought years). In other words we are losing low-yielding vineyard and replacing it with grape growing on an industrial scale.

There are therefore a few issues at play. The one is whether the calamity of Covid-19 (and the way the pandemic has been managed) is the cause of the crisis; the other is whether or not – excluding the question of the impact in human terms – this is a good or bad thing. The first is easily answered: the surplus wine lying unsold in bulk storage as the vintage approaches is very much a victim of the lockdown, of six weeks of exports lost in March and April 2020, of a grievously wounded hospitality industry, of a massively depressed economy. For those who think that alcohol is the last item removed from household budgets in a recession this may come as a surprise; those of us who know better are aware that in depressed times consumers buy down, or don’t buy at all.

At the very bottom of the pricing pyramid is what is euphemistically known as “ale.” Made from the fermentation of yeast, sugar and water, sometimes flavoured, often not, this is the safest of the illegal concoctions which have flourished since the formal market was driven underground in the last three months of prohibition. For wine drinkers whose daily tipple pre-pandemic was supplied in papsakke, ale has been the most likely substitution.

When wineries sit with unsold inventory and see little prospect of a real turnaround in the next 12 months, they cut back on forward inventory. This means that they reduce the tonnage of grapes they buy for processing in 2021. Their current stocks have been paid for: to buy fruit from the 2021 vintage would have cashflow implications at a time when sales are depressed. Anybody with a high school economics credit (so not necessarily the people making the decisions driving the country’s business prospects) would know that less fruit will be purchased when the grape harvest begins. And since the growers need to pay for their farming costs (incurred since sometime in 2020) and their crop is worthless if it cannot be processed, the extent of the impending disaster is unimaginable.

We already know that the cheapest (but not the best) grapes come from high-yielding vineyards, most (though not all) from the riverine appellations far inland. This in turn means that the worst of the attrition of the current crisis will be felt by the growers of lower yielding (often older) vineyards of the so-called Coastal Region: Stellenbosch, Paarl, Swartland. So the impact will wreak a swathe of destruction exactly where our finest wines are produced and where the better-healed wine tourists visit – which pretty much answers the question of whether or not this is a good or bad thing for the wine industry.

  • Michael Fridjhon has over thirty-five years’ experience in the liquor industry. He is the founder of Winewizard.co.za and holds various positions including Visiting Professor of Wine Business at the University of Cape Town; founder and director of WineX – the largest consumer wine show in the Southern Hemisphere and chairman of The Old Mutual Trophy Wine Show.

Attention: Articles like this take time and effort to create. We need your support to make our work possible. To make a financial contribution, click here. Invoice available upon request – contact info@winemag.co.za


4 comment(s)

Please read our Comments Policy here.

    Delia Foster | 29 January 2021

    Dear Michael
    I have read with horror, the situation that SA vineyards are facing.
    This is just a brief and hopefully encouraging email, from a VERY senior English lady, to make you smile!
    I have today taken delivery of 1 case of Barista Pinotage, 2 cases of Ken Forester Chenin and 2 cases of Graham Beck pink Fizz!!! ( this should last me a week or two!!)
    Our Majestic Wine warehouses have excellent stock of SA wines and we are not
    rationed! I do hope things will improve for your industry.
    When my Husband was alive, we spent such wonderful holidays at Eikendal Lodge in Stellenbosh, and walking through the vineyards was a joy. Nothing in my mind compares to wines from your Country.
    We have vineyards in England that are doing quite well.. the grapes to make the sparkling wines seem to thrive here.
    Best Wishes from a fan of SA wines, and indeed your wonderful Country. Let’s all hope this Pandemic is soon wiped out and some sort of normality returns
    Delia Foster
    West Sussex

      Michael Fridjhon | 1 February 2021

      Hi Delia
      Your support of the Cape wine industry is obviously vital and appreciated by all whose livelihood depends on the broadest distribution of our wines. It’s a great sadness that the industry has become a political football: the ANC’s prohibitionist agenda is one of the few unifiers in a very fractured political movement. It has also become increasingly clear that those who wish to undermine the industry traffic in very questionable statistics. I agree that standing up to the disinformation is the only way forward.

    Tim Brink | 15 January 2021

    Political agenda seeking destruction of an industry that can’t be funneled apart from tax revenues.
    This has nothing to do with Covid and beds.
    As for the employees facing doom, they are pawns in the ANCs game.
    It’s going to turn messy and that’s when the ANC will pounce decrying landowners and farmers callous to spread their vitriol.
    It’s the ANC way, we have seen it before.

    Greg Garden | 14 January 2021

    Setting aside some pertinent points relating to the SAB/ABInBev legal challenge to the third prohibition, but not necessarily apposite to your article Michael (such as their shot-in-the-foot social media ‘influencer’ campaign, ABI’s reputation for arrogance and non-collaboration, and – a superficial view I admit – the strangeness of some of their reported legal argument) I urge the wine industry to follow their lead. If business sectors do not by now know that there is zero upside to ‘playing nice’ with this government, then they partially deserve their fate. They may not have made the bed, but by choosing to lie in it, or by adopting a soft negotiation stance for the sake of hoped for longer term relations, such industries, including Wine, end up condoning the evil. “It’s hard to avoid the conclusion that the ANC is more concerned with driving an anti-alcohol agenda than applying a more sophisticated and segmented approach which would manage risk while sustaining economic activity”. Absolutely! So please SA wine industry, with whatever support you need from whichever stakeholders can assist in any way, publicly and formally challenge these unconstitutional chains now, before you have nothing left to lose.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Like our content?

Show your support.