Perspective: When 97, 93 and 88 all describe the same wine
By Christian Eedes, 16 November 2026
1
What is a sensible rating for The Left Bank Stellenbosch Cabernet Sauvignon Merlot 2021 from Neil Ellis? Earlier this year, it scored 97 and won the Riedel Trophy for Best Bordeaux-style Red Blend at the Investec Trophy Wine Show. Full disclosure: I chaired the category panel that nominated the wine for the trophy taste-off. The 2026 edition of Platter’s, by contrast, awards it 88. The online wine community Vivino gives the 2021 a rating of 4.1 out of 5, based on 55 individual assessments. Ratings of 4.0 or above are relatively uncommon on the platform: according to Vivino, such wines rank better than 85% of the 9.5 million wines in its database, with a 4.0 rating correlating to an expert score of 90 points.
Intrigued by the Trophy Wine Show stickers and curious to revisit what the competition panel had seen in it, I recently bought a bottle (price: R225). The blend comprises 49% Cabernet Sauvignon, 36% Merlot, 8% Cabernet Franc and 7% Malbec, and was matured for 17 months in barrel, 30% new.
The nose shows cassis, some leafiness, violets and pencil shavings. The palate is medium-bodied, with pure fruit, fresh acidity and fine tannins, the finish uncompromisingly dry. There is all the precision one expects from this producer, although the overall impression is of a wine that is essentially unfussy rather than thrilling. Alcohol: 14%.
My assessment? A very good wine, impeccably made and particularly well priced, but not one that I would describe as world-class. At Winemag, 93 points represents gold-standard quality; 95 is reserved for wines of genuine world-class distinction. Maintaining that distinction matters. If every very good wine is deemed exceptional, the language of wine criticism becomes progressively less useful.
CE’s rating: 93 | Value
Check out our South African wine ratings database.


Josua | 16 November 2026
Every year there seems to be wines that score 95+ at the ITWS that, in retrospect, get downgraded or are poorly received by consumers relative to the score.