Greg Sherwood MW: Government Lockdown Madness

By , 22 April 2020

Comment

3

It’s now lockdown day 20-something and counting. You will hopefully excuse my slightly vague use of dates and timings in this editorial piece as I don’t really know what day of the week it is let alone exactly how many days it’s been since lockdown was announced to be honest. All I remember is that South Africa announced its draconian total shut down a few days after the UK was already in full national self-isolation. My mantra then, as it remains now, was ‘keep calm and carry on drinking’.

However it seems that if, unlike me, you do not happen to have over 1,400 bottles of fine wine squirreled away in every nook and cranny of your house plus two cellars under the house, total lockdown might present itself as a rather distressing and daunting time. In the UK, we of course awaited the lockdown with bated breath and when it was eventually announced, the date of which eludes me, we were simultaneously relieved and distraught in equal measure. But like all common-sense democracies, the UK government was wise enough to acknowledge that if they chose to follow the legislated route of social distancing and shut down every bar, pub and restaurant in the country, it was obvious that they would not also be able to prohibit retailers, merchants and supermarkets from selling alcohol and tobacco. That surely would be madness personified! After all, America has its liberty and its right to bear arms and the UK has its right to consume alcohol… both at levels that may or may not prove detrimental to one’s own health or the health of others.

Haulage of wine is currently not happening.

But of course, one needs to separate the tendency to self-harm versus the need to harm the nation as a whole, and that is exactly what the South African government chose to inflict on the population in its nationwide ban of alcohol sales and exports. As the country moved from a “no you can’t” to a “maybe” to a “yes you can” export status, hopes lifted and indeed at the time of writing my last Letter from London for Winemag.co.za, the decision was merely a day away from the South African government changing tact, allowing limited exports of wine and spirits to start proceeding once again. The subsequent time line becomes hazy once again but within one or two days, this decision seemed to be reversed. The reason? Well, the only one I have heard anecdotally being the South African governments inability to safeguard the transportation of wine and alcohol shipments to the Cape Town harbour and other national ports.

In all seriousness, this is something I write about with a very heavy heart. Only just today, I ‘penned’ a letter of support for the Cape Winemakers Guild Chairlady as part of their lobbying of the South African government alongside the broader South African wine industry, in an attempt to reverse this perverse policy of madness and self-flagellation. My missive (which you can read here: CWG Lockdown Letter) acknowledges the sensible desires of the government to try and temper the level and intensity of alcohol consumption during the local national lockdown, but what I just cannot understand, together with the entire South African wine industry, is the willingness of the South African government to commit to a policy of self- and national harm. After all, the South African exchequer is ultimately the net winner or loser in this game. Banning exports of South African wines and spirits is madness!

I’m generally not one to indulge in conspiracy theories, but my mind has been consumed by this issue over the past weeks. Reading the sub-text from government and proponents of the export ban, I have been unable to come to any other conclusion other than this being a blatant overt political move on behalf of the national ANC lead government to utilise this moment of fragility and weakness in the Western Cape’s armour, which is lead by the opposition Democratic Party on a provincial level, to deliver a resounding blow to the heart of its economy and most of its citizen’s livelihoods. After all, the next biggest income generator for the Western Cape, its tourism industry, has already been dealt a crushing blow by the ANC’s newly adopted bedfellow, Covid-19.

Well, there it is… I’ve said it. No doubt I will get a lot of stick for this line of thinking, but with what is at stake, I am more than happy to walk a sensitive line and call out this situation as I really see it. The damage being done in Europe and other international markets for South African wines is incalculable and unfortunately, we will only really see the true results of Covid-19 and the ANC government’s policies months after the crisis has subsided. What is assured is that however transient the Covid-19 illness proves to be in South Africa’s national context, the damage entrenched by the government’s ill conceived and foolish policies will very sadly prove to be long lasting.

  • Greg Sherwood was born in Pretoria, South Africa, and as the son of a career diplomat, spent his first 21 years travelling the globe with his parents. With a Business Management and Marketing degree from Webster University, St. Louis, Missouri, USA, Sherwood began his working career as a commodity trader. In 2000, he decided to make more of a long-held interest in wine taking a position at Handford Wines in South Kensington, London and is today Senior Wine Buyer. He became a Master of Wine in 2007.

Attention: Articles like this take time and effort to create. We need your support to make our work possible. To make a financial contribution, click here. Invoice available upon request – contact info@winemag.co.za

Comments

3 comment(s)

  • Rolff van der Linden29 April 2020

    Bullseye.
    Exactly the reason for shutting down everything to do with wine and alcohol. Political pressure on a non ANC controlled province.
    The ANC is the worst thing that has happened to SA. It was saved from a deep recession and looming bankruptcy by a little virus CV19. It followed a dodgy Chinese protocol of shutdown. Then started the huge ‘funds’ for help and business rescue.
    The ANC now controls everyone in SA and will support who it chooses. Cadres and ANC bank accounts will be awash with much needed funding.
    SOE funding has dried up……. this will make SOE thefts look like small change.
    Let’s hope sanity will soon prevail and ALL businesses open again.
    I hope our wine industry survives this stupidity.

  • Lauren28 April 2020

    Great article! I too cannot understand why the ban on exports and wish (for purely selfish reasons) that online wine sales would be allowed. It has been 5 weeks of lockdown and it seems that we will have at least (hopefully less but probably likely more) another 3 or 4 weeks till we get to Level 3 (where alcohol may be sold – we hope so at least). I think they are being unreasonable if they do not open up online wine sales if exports are opened up… We will wait and see!

  • Billabong25 April 2020

    Well said. It is either complete incompetence or pure spite. You make a good case for the latter and I applaud you for saying it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Like our content?

Show your support.

Contribute